Labour Day

The results of the Labour selection process are here, but could be removed at any point, lack commentary and, in the party’s ongoing obsession with regions, are not in nice alphabetical order – so my version below is better!

By my reckoning 32,781 Labour party members voted in these elections. 12 of the 41 candidates were unopposed, and so won without a postal ballot. In 1 of these cases (Suffolk) a shortlisted candidate withdrew, producing an uncontested result. In other cases competing candidates were not allowed onto what became a shortlist of one.

The following points summarise the results for me:-

  • There are a fair few ex-MPs and ex-Ministers whose high profile will have helped them get elected.
  • Some of these high-profile figures had very close results. Lord Prescott won the Humberside nomination with 552 votes, only 94 votes ahead of a former policeman who had recently become politically active. Alun Michael won the South Wales nomination with 1,142 votes, only 82 votes ahead of another ex-cop. If senior figures can’t win Labour hearts with such established reputations it does not auger well if they are representing Labour outside of safe Labour territory – and Humberside is one such place.
  • The party has therefore chosen some high-profile politicians by a whisker, ahead of people with police knowledge and experience, exactly the opposite of what polling is telling us that voters want and expect in PCC candidates. Yet the high votes for relatively unknown ex-cops underlines the fact that this experience is valued by voters. Labour have ended up with a risky strategy, effectively chosen by a handful of Labour party members. It represents an opportunity for their opponents who have yet to select candidates.
  • The election featured online campaigning, emails, and use of Twitter, but to what effect? Paul Richards and Jon Harvey could hardly have had higher online political profiles, but still lost.
  • Some tell me that about half the Labour membership list don’t have email addresses, a problem in a place like Lancashire where, mid-election, Clive Grunshaw was ordered to apologise to his opponents for comments about them in a campaign leaflet. Their statements were emailed to party members, but it looks like half the membership could vote without knowing this fact, and the party is left with a candidate who they have found guilty of breaking the rules.
  • The election featured candidates seeking and winning union endorsements, with mailshots paid for by unions. Given the margins of victory in some cases this may have made a real difference in candidate selection. Some of these unions represent police staff. Was this money well spent by the unions, and what is the impact on democracy if it was?
  • Unless the November elections produce a Bradford West style upset, these internal elections (including the Conservative selections) were the real elections in about half to two-thirds of the available contests :- and in media terms no one was looking while they were going on.

Congratulations to all winning candidates. Commisserations to the rest. Now the fun begins.


Avon and Somerset

ASHFORD, Bob. 891 Elected

SAVAGE, John. 505


HEFFERNAN, Adrian 190

MARTINS, Oliver 511 Elected


MURPHY, Ed 265 Elected

ROGERS, Ruth 241


CARTER, Steve 375

STOCKTON, John 471 Elected


BRASH, Jonathan 157

COPPINGER, Barry 523 Elected


BOADEN, Mike 190

LEONARD, Patrick 225 Elected


CHARLES, Alan. 695 Elected

DHINDSA, Hardyal. 365

SALT, Kathryn. 133

Devon and Cornwall

CANAVAN, Patrick 312

WILLIAMS, Nicky 591 Elected



ROGERS, Rachael Elected Unopposed


Round 1 2

DIXON, Bill 330 427

HOGG, Ron 423 536 Elected

THOMPSON, Peter 311

Dyfed Powys

GWYTHER, Christine Elected Unopposed


COOK, Val Morris 449 Elected

NEWELL, Jordan 355


DHANDA, Rupi Elected Unopposed

Greater Manchester

LLOYD, Tony Elected Unopposed


SANDISON, Hamish 494 Elected

WORRAD, Joshua 306


HAGGER, Alan 335

RAYMENT, Jacqui 576 Elected


BATSON, Sherma Elected Unopposed


HUNTER, Keith. 458

PRESCOTT, John. 552 Elected


BATES, Steve 241

YEO, Harriet 711 Elected


Round 1 2

ATKINSON, Mark 342

GRUNSHAW, Clive 820 966 Elected

MASTER, Ibby 532 663


RUSSELL, Sarah Elected unopposed


DILKS, Phil. 218 Elected

GLEESON, Paul. 97


Round 1. 2.

KENNEDY, Jane. 895. 974

KILFOYLE, Peter. 745. 833



BURKE, Stephen 232

MORPHEW, Steve 337 Elected


BAIRD, Vera 1,921 Elected

FOSTER, Tom 635

North Wales

HANSON, Margaret 276

MICHAEL, Tal 548 Elected

North Yorkshire

POTTER, Ruth Elected Unopposed


BARRON, Lee. 212 Elected



MOHAMMED, Adam. 841

TIPPING, Paddy. 892 Elected

South Wales

CANNON, Paul 1,058

MICHAEL, Alun 1,142 Elected

South Yorkshire

Round 1. 2. 3.
BILLINGS, Alan. 461. 592.
HUGHES, Med. 382.
WALAYAT, Kash. 622. 671. 861
WRIGHT, Shaun. 972. 1,116. 1,353 Elected


GARNER, Joy 402 Elected

POULTER, Michael 351


BASHAM, Jane Elected Unopposed


EVANS, Robert Elected Unopposed


DANIEL, Godfrey 679 Elected

RICHARDS, Paul 554

Thames Valley

HARVEY, Jon 590

STARKEY, Tim 614 Elected


EDWARDS, Claire 102

PLASKITT, James 291 Elected

West Mercia

MURPHY, Simon Elected Unopposed

West Midlands

JONES, Bob 1,580 Elected

MOSQUITO, Yvonne. 827

West Yorkshire

BURNS-WILLIAMSON, Mark Elected Unopposed


MOODY, Clare Elected Unopposed


This entry was posted in Labour, Perspectives, Selecting Candidates and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Labour Day

  1. ianchisnall says:

    For all sorts of obvious reasons to people who have been following this blog, the loss of Jon and Paul Richards to this contest is very sad.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s